The 3 Myths of Board Retreats...and How to Bust Them!
Planning a board retreat? Here’s how to make sure it’s a success using the experience of a Capacity Partners longstanding client: Avalon Theatre, a local independent film center and one of the country’s longest operating theaters. We opened the retreat with a classic icebreaker: “What was the opening film of The Avalon in 1923?” (It stumped no one.)
We should start with the assumption that we know who the retreat stakeholders are: 1) the board as a group; 2) the Facilitator; and 3) you, the Executive Director. Each of these stakeholders has a myth that must be busted. Get these myths out of the way at the earliest planning:
Myth 1, by the Executive Director: “We will have full board attendance.”
Busted: It will not happen. Plan the retreat without Zoom/MS Teams, so the in-person attendees can focus. Then steer the executive summary toward a call to action in order to extract commitments from board members.
Myth 2, by the Board Members: “Why am I giving up my kids’ soccer game for this?”
Busted: This means you will probably make 95% of your kids’ games because you are a dedicated parent, and the dedication you bring to the retreat also will help teach your kids to be future community leaders.
Myth 3, by the Facilitator: “The Facilitator wants to be liked, for the retreat to end on a high note (and to get tons of referrals).”
Busted: Craving likeability gets in the way of achieving consensus. Consensus is not when everyone agrees; it is when everyone agrees to defer to the organization’s greater good. They are not mutually exclusive, but there is a difference.
I was asked by my client to be The Enforcer, as much as The Facilitator. As we rank priorities and gain momentum on shared concerns, the one-offs, the pet projects tended to lose steam. Strong board members may repeat those one-offs, and the Facilitator/Enforcer/Bad Guy is the one who reminds the group that in the interest of priorities and clear vision (and time!) we should stay focused on the Big Goal.
Don’t Lose Sight of the Big Goal
The Big Goal in this case became clear as the board kept their vision on the organization’s #1 stakeholder group, the filmgoers. Facing the threat of reduced government funding for the arts, the board could easily see that investment in top-of-the-line equipment to guarantee an exceptional in-person experience would position The Avalon for the future. A thoughtful board is indeed a treasure.
A good facilitator can engage the entire board. They make it fun: they let the group set the rules; they draw out the silent sage; they pick on the good-natured talker; they threaten to keep the group past the time; they accept silence; they celebrate successes. They make the last hour the best hour.
One Closing Suggestion
Go into your retreat with the expectation that there will not be a follow-up retreat. The Board Chair should not let the group use a follow-up as an opportunity to kick the can down the road. Boards exist to make leadership decisions. If you want a really good retreat, decide that this is it, unless there are compelling reasons otherwise (e.g., you need more information or new topics are brought up that were not on the original agenda.). Making decisions will serve your planning, and will ensure that consensus, unanimity, friendship and shared vision will carry your organization to the next level.
Icebreaker resource: www.theavalon.org

